Where Social Media Screening fits with the New Harassment Duties
Since 30 October 2026, employers in England, Wales and Scotland must take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment, and can be liable when third parties harass their staff. Social media screening is not required, but for roles where online conduct poses a real risk, a structured, transparent check can form part of a wider approach to protecting people.
The new duties have put conduct at the centre of the hiring conversation, and many employers are asking whether their process would spot behaviour that matters before someone joins. As an experienced employment background screening provider, we explain what changed, where social media screening fits, and what good screening looks like in practice.
What Changed on 30 October 2026?
Two changes made by the Employment Rights Act 2025 came into force on 30 October 2026. The duty to take “reasonable steps” to prevent sexual harassment became a duty to take “all reasonable steps”, and employers became liable for harassment of their employees by third parties unless they took all reasonable steps to prevent it.
A third party is anyone who is not the employer or one of its employees, such as customers, clients, contractors and visitors. The third-party protection also covers harassment related to any relevant protected characteristic under the Equality Act 2010, not only sexual harassment.
The stakes are significant. The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) can take enforcement action even where no harassment has taken place, and where a tribunal upholds a sexual harassment claim and finds the duty was breached, compensation can be increased by up to 25% (EHRC technical guidance). The law does not list the steps employers must take, and regulations setting some out are not expected before 2027.
Where does Social Media fit in the New Duties?
Social media fits because harassment does not stay in the office. The EHRC’s guidance lists posts and contact on social media as forms of unwanted conduct, identifies social media contact between workers as a risk factor, and says anti-harassment policies should cover online behaviour, including on personal devices.
Most of that is about managing conduct within the workforce through policy, training and complaint handling. But it also raises a fair question at the hiring stage: if someone has a public record of harassing, threatening or abusing people online, would your process know?
References and employment verification confirm facts such as dates and job titles, and criminal record checks show convictions. None of them shows how someone behaves in public online. Social media screening addresses a different part of the risk picture by looking at relevant publicly available online conduct. For some roles, an employer may decide that such screening is justified as part of its broader recruitment risk framework.
Does the New Duty require Social Media Screening?
No. Neither the Employment Rights Act 2025 nor the EHRC’s guidance names social media screening, or pre-employment checks of any kind, as a required step. The duty is about the working environment an employer creates and controls.
This mirrors the position in financial services, where the FCA’s non-financial misconduct rules widened the conduct firms must take seriously while making clear they are not expected to monitor private lives or social media. Our blog on what the FCA’s non-financial misconduct rules mean for hiring covers that in detail.
Where social media screening tends to make sense is in roles where the risk is clearest: people managers with authority over others, senior leaders who set the tone of a workplace culture, and roles with close contact with colleagues, customers or the public in sensitive settings. The decision should be deliberate and documented, and it should sit alongside the workplace measures the duty asks for, not replace them.
A duty to prevent harassment is not a licence to look, but it is a reason to look properly where it matters.
What should Social Media Screening look for?
Social media screening should look for conduct, not opinions. That lines up closely with what the harassment duties are about: behaviour that violates people’s dignity or puts them at risk.
Relevant conduct typically includes:
- Hate speech and discriminatory language
- Threats, violent content or the glorification of violence
- Harassment or bullying of others
- Evidence of illegal activity
Screening should focus on defined, role-relevant conduct. Irrelevant information, like lawful political views, religious beliefs, lifestyle choices, family life and protected characteristics, should not form part of review or hiring decision. Assessing them is unfair, and it invites the very discrimination claims the Equality Act exists to prevent.
Real findings bear this out. In a social media screening programme Accurate ran for a retail business, 70 of 256 checks returned adverse information. Hate and discriminatory behaviour and violent content were the most common categories, while extreme views and opinions accounted for none of the flags (Accurate social media screening case study).
Screening done well finds behaviour, not beliefs.
What does a good Social Media Screening programme include
A good programme starts with a written policy and ends with a recorded decision, with consistency at every step in between. Drawing on Accurate’s work with clients and the Information Commissioner’s Office’s (ICO) expectations, it includes:
- A clear policy objective. A written policy explains why screening is used and what it is for. It should never be ad hoc.
- A defined risk appetite. The organisation decides in advance what online behaviour is unacceptable, ideally aligned with its anti-harassment policy, so findings are judged against a standard rather than instinct.
- A proportionate scope. Checks are used for roles with a clear reason. The ICO says employers should not routinely vet all candidates unless legally required to.
- Transparency. Candidates are told before any check takes place, as the ICO requires.
- Consistent criteria. Every candidate for a role is reviewed in the same way, against the same conduct categories.
- Separation of research and decision. The people reviewing content are not the people deciding whether to hire.
- A right to respond. Candidates can explain or put context around anything found before it is relied on.
- A clear record. What was checked, what was found and how the decision was reached are documented, helping demonstrate that the screening process itself was structured, consistent and accountable.
Who should look, and who should decide?
The person who reviews a candidate’s social media should not be the person who decides whether to hire them. The ICO says staff who research candidates’ profiles “should not also make the recruitment decisions about them”, and it is one of the most widely ignored safeguards in practice.
A social media profile can reveal someone’s religion, health, sexual orientation and political views within seconds. Once a hiring manager has seen that, it cannot be unseen. Before working with Accurate, the retail client’s hiring managers had been carrying out their own informal searches. With a structured process in place, the client told hiring managers only that something had been flagged, without passing on the content, and there was no pushback where offers were withdrawn.
Informal searching feels harmless until you have to explain it.
How should employers use what they find?
A finding should start a conversation, not end one. Not every red flag should lead to an offer being withdrawn: the right response depends on the employer’s policy, the role, how serious and how recent the content is, and what the candidate says.
Some content, such as threats or hate speech, can have serious legal implications. A post from many years ago may not reflect who someone is today. And because the ICO notes that information found online may not be accurate, candidates should have the chance to comment before it is relied on. In the retail case study, the client discussed a finding with the candidate, the candidate took action on their account, and a repeat check came back clear.
When is Social Media Screening hard to defend?
Social media screening is hard to defend when it is used without a clear reason, without the candidate’s knowledge, or to judge who someone is rather than how they behave. Four situations cause most problems: blanket checks on every applicant, checks candidates are not told about, checks that assess opinions or lifestyle, and hiring managers searching for themselves.
| Informal searching | Structured social media screening | |
| Who looks | Usually the hiring manager | A reviewer separate from the decision-maker |
| What they see | Everything, including protected characteristics | Only findings relevant to agreed conduct categories |
| Consistency | Varies by searcher and candidate | Same criteria for every candidate in a role |
| Candidate awareness | Often not disclosed | Candidates told in advance |
| Record | Little or nothing to show | Scope, findings and decision documented |
How can Accurate help?
Accurate helps organisations decide whether social media screening has a place in their hiring process and, where it does, design it to be relevant, consistent and fair, so they can hire with confidence. Our experts review online activity against the conduct that matters to each client, and we advise on how to respond to results, including when a finding does not need to change a hiring decision.
We have provided employment background screening since 2006, and our information security management system is ISO 27001 certified. For many roles, well-run pre-employment screening will be proportionate on its own. Where social media screening does fit, our social media screening case study shows how one employer approached it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do the new harassment duties apply to all employers?
Yes. The duty to take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment, and liability for third-party harassment, apply to employers of every size in England, Wales and Scotland. What counts as reasonable varies with factors such as the size and resources of the organisation, its sector and how much contact staff have with the public.
Is social media screening one of the “reasonable steps”?
It is not named in the law or the EHRC’s guidance, so it is not a required step. Some employers choose it for roles where online conduct poses a clear risk, as part of a wider approach that also includes risk assessment, policy, training and complaint handling. Where it is used, it should be proportionate, transparent and documented.
Is social media screening legal in the UK?
Social media screening can be lawful in the UK, but employers need to comply with data protection and equality law. The purpose and scope of the check should be justified by a specific risk associated with the role, limited to what is necessary and proportionate, and explained to the candidate. Employers should also take particular care with irrelevant or sensitive personal information revealed through online profiles and should not rely on online information alone when making a hiring decision.
Can hiring managers just search for candidates online?
It is best avoided. Informal searches vary from one candidate to the next, expose hiring managers to protected characteristics and leave nothing to show how a decision was made. The ICO also says the person researching a candidate’s social media should not be the person making the recruitment decision.
Does a red flag mean we should withdraw the offer?
Not necessarily. It depends on your policy and risk appetite, the role, how serious and recent the content is, and what the candidate says when given the chance to respond. In Accurate’s retail case study, one finding was resolved after the client discussed it with the candidate and a repeat check came back clear.
Talk to our team
If you are reviewing your hiring process in light of the new harassment duties, or want to replace informal searching with something you can stand behind, talk to our team about whether social media screening has a place in it.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.