Skipping background checks means hiring on whatever a candidate chooses to tell you. For UK employers, the risks run from civil penalties of up to £60,000 per worker for missed right to work checks, to fraud, data theft, regulatory breaches and the cost of replacing a bad hire. Accurate, the employment background screening provider, helps HR teams hire with confidence through checks that are proportionate, consistent and defensible.
With competition for talent high, the pressure to get people in and contributing quickly can make skipping background checks look attractive. But every new hire brings some risk with them, and in 2026 the rules around hiring are tightening. Here is what HR Directors and HR Managers are really risking, and how to screen well without slowing hiring down.
What are businesses risking?
Taking on someone without carrying out a professional screening process gives that person the power to decide what they want to tell you about themselves, and that isn’t always going to be the full picture. The risk of skipping background checks such as Accurate’s will cross-check information from multiple sources to give a full and complete employment timeline. This means candidates cannot ‘forget’ to mention a workplace which may not have been so good for them. Education qualifications can also be properly verified, and references thoroughly checked for their origin – rather than leaving the possibility that they have been provided by a friend.
Employers going it alone are also at risk of accepting fraudulent documents or even being targeted by someone who might use an employment service which falsely supplies everything from CVs to references.
| Key takeaways: Every UK employer must carry out right to work checks, and getting them wrong can lead to a civil penalty of up to £60,000 per illegal worker. From 1 October 2026, the illegal working rules extend to workers, individual sub-contractors and online platforms, not just employees. In Cifas research published in February 2025, 18% of UK adults said they had lied on a CV or job application in the past year, or knew someone who had. From 1 January 2027, employees can claim unfair dismissal after six months rather than two years, so getting the hiring decision right first time matters more than ever. |
What are the risks of skipping background checks?
The main risk of skipping background checks is making a hiring decision on incomplete information. Without independent verification, the candidate decides what you know about their employment history, qualifications, identity and right to work, and that is not always the full picture. The consequences tend to fall into five areas.
| Risk | What it looks like | Why it matters |
| Legal and compliance | A missed right to work check, or no DBS check or regulatory reference where one is required | Civil penalties, criminal liability and regulatory action |
| Fraud and financial loss | Falsified qualifications, fake references or a hidden history of dishonesty | Direct losses and the cost of replacing the hire |
| Data and IP theft | A new starter with system access who is not who they claim to be | Data breaches, ICO scrutiny and lost client trust |
| Workplace safety | Someone with relevant unspent convictions working with vulnerable people | Harm to people and safeguarding failures |
| Reputational damage | A senior hire whose history becomes public after they join | Lost clients and a damaged employer brand |
Professional screening closes these gaps by cross-checking information from several sources. A verified employment timeline means a candidate cannot simply ‘forget’ a workplace that did not go well, qualifications are confirmed with the awarding body, and references are traced to a genuine former employer rather than a friend doing a favour.
Which background checks are a legal requirement in the UK?
Right to work checks are the only background check every UK employer is legally expected to carry out, and they must be completed before someone starts work. Other checks are required only for certain roles and sectors. Beyond those, UK data protection law expects any screening to be necessary and proportionate to the risks of the role.
| Check | When it is required or expected | Where the rule comes from |
| Right to work | Everyone before they start, including workers, some sub-contractors and platform workers from 1 October 2026 | Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006, as amended |
| Standard or enhanced DBS check | Eligible roles, such as work with children or vulnerable adults and certain regulated professions | Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (Exceptions) Order 1975 |
| Fit and proper checks and regulatory references | Senior managers and certified staff in FCA-regulated firms | FCA Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) |
| BS7858 security screening | Security roles, often as a client or contract requirement | British Standard BS7858 (an industry standard, not law) |
| Employment history, qualifications, credit, sanctions and social media checks | A risk-based decision for each role | UK GDPR and ICO employment guidance |
The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) says pre-employment vetting should reflect specific risks, and that employers should not routinely vet every candidate unless the law requires it. So the risk cuts both ways: checking too little leaves the business exposed, while checking too much or inconsistently creates problems of its own. Our guide on which pre-employment checks you need goes into more detail by role.
What changes to right to work checks from 1 October 2026?
From 1 October 2026, the UK’s illegal working rules reach beyond traditional employees. Under the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025, brought into force by SI 2026/683, businesses can be liable for people on non-employee contracts, individual sub-contractors and people matched to work through online platforms.
GOV.UK sets the civil penalty at up to £60,000 per illegal worker, with first breaches at up to £45,000, and knowingly employing someone without the right to work carries up to five years in prison. The Home Office published a draft code of practice on 30 June 2026 and a draft update to its employer’s guide on 11 September 2026, so check the latest version before updating your process. The practical question for HR is who in your labour supply chain is now your responsibility, and whether you could evidence a compliant check for each of them.
How common is CV fraud in the UK?
CV fraud is more common than many hiring managers assume. In research published by Cifas, the UK’s fraud prevention service, in February 2025, 18% of UK adults said they had lied on a CV or job application in the previous 12 months, or knew someone who had, and 14% felt it was reasonable to exaggerate their qualifications.
Fake references are part of the same picture. Cifas’s Workplace Fraud Trends 2025 survey of 2,000 employees at large UK organisations found that 19% had used a fake job reference or knew someone who had, and 30% thought using a reference house, a service that supplies made-up references, was justifiable. We look at how these services work in the rise of the fake employment reference.
Our own data shows why verification matters. In a recent 12-month period, 53% of the candidates Accurate screened had gaps in their career history, and half of those gaps lasted six months or more. Most gaps have good explanations, from caring responsibilities to study. The risk comes when a gap is hidden rather than explained, which is why we looked at how employers are investigating career gaps.
How much does a bad hire cost a UK business?
A bad hire costs far more than a salary, because the business pays to recruit, onboard and train someone, then pays again to replace them. Early exits are more common than many leaders expect. The CIPD’s Resourcing and talent planning report 2024, based on a YouGov survey of 1,016 UK HR professionals, found that 41% of organisations that had recruited in the past year saw new recruits resign within their first 12 weeks at least some of the time.
The costs climb with seniority, and again if the new hire acts against the business. Cifas insider threat data shows how early that can happen: in 2023, 38% of the people recorded on its Insider Threat Database for dishonest conduct had been in their role for less than a year, up from 21% in 2022.
Waiting a day or two for the right checks is almost always cheaper than unwinding the wrong hire.
How does the Employment Rights Act 2025 raise the stakes?
The Employment Rights Act 2025 shortens the window for correcting a hiring mistake easily. According to Acas, from 1 January 2027 employees can claim unfair dismissal after six months in a job rather than two years, and from 1 October 2026 the time limit for most tribunal claims extends from three months to six.
Employers can still dismiss after six months, but concerns about honesty or suitability that surface later will need a fair reason and a fair process. Finding out that someone misrepresented their background before an offer becomes unconditional is a far easier conversation than finding out nine months in. Our overview of the new employment laws covers the wider changes.
Why is DIY background screening risky?
Running background checks in-house can look like a saving, but it often leaves gaps that cost more later, especially where legal or international requirements are complex. Most HR teams do not have the tools to spot a well-made forged certificate, the access to verify an overseas qualification, or the time to trace every reference. The most common gaps are:
- Inconsistency. Different hiring managers check different things for the same role, which is hard to defend if a decision is challenged.
- Fraudulent documents and references. Fake certificates and reference houses are designed to pass a quick look.
- Data protection risk. Collecting too much, keeping it too long, or searching candidates informally online can breach UK GDPR and expose decision-makers to protected characteristics.
- International complexity. 40% of the checks Accurate carries out are international, and each country has its own rules.
- No audit trail. Without a record of what was checked and why, it is hard to show a regulator, tribunal or client that your process was defensible.
If social media checks have a place in your process, our guide to the FCA’s non-financial misconduct rules explains how to keep them structured and proportionate.
Does remote and hybrid working make background checks more important?
Yes, because remote hiring removes many of the moments where something that does not add up would be noticed. Identity needs to be properly confirmed rather than assumed from a video call, and employers need to know whether a candidate is already committed elsewhere.
Cifas’s Workplace Fraud Trends 2025 research found that 19% of employees had secretly worked for a competing employer at the same time, or knew someone who had. For senior appointments, it is also worth checking for directorships elsewhere that could create a conflict of interest with the new role.
How do background checks support the failure to prevent fraud offence?
For large organisations, screening can form part of the reasonable procedures needed to defend against the failure to prevent fraud offence. Since 1 September 2025, organisations meeting two of three thresholds (more than 250 employees, turnover above £36 million, balance sheet above £18 million) can face an unlimited fine if an employee or other associated person commits fraud to benefit the organisation and reasonable prevention procedures were not in place.
The Home Office guidance lists “vetting checks if appropriate” among the due diligence measures organisations can use, and expects procedures to be proportionate and risk-based. A consistent, documented process for vetting people in higher-risk roles is one of the clearest ways to show that fraud risk was taken seriously.
Do background checks slow down hiring?
Background checks do not need to hold up hiring. Digital ID checks, instant employment verification and online DBS applications mean many checks now take days rather than weeks, and a basic DBS check takes around three days on average, according to the DBS.
Candidates notice a slow or clunky process, so speed still matters. The aim is speed without the risk. Some providers focus on helping organisations hire faster. Accurate helps organisations hire with confidence.
What should HR Directors do now?
The most useful step is to make sure every hiring decision rests on checks that are consistent, proportionate and properly recorded:
- Map your roles by risk and agree the checks each group of roles needs.
- Review who is in scope for right to work, including contractors, sub-contractors and platform workers, against the rules from 1 October 2026.
- Write down your screening policy: what you check for each role, why, and how long you keep the information.
- Make offers conditional on satisfactory checks and complete them before the start date wherever possible.
- Stop informal checks by hiring managers outside the agreed process, and tell candidates which checks you run and why.
- Plan for [rescreening](rescreen) when people move into higher-risk roles, and keep an audit trail of every decision.
How Accurate helps
Accurate has provided employment background screening in the UK since 2006, supporting employers across the UK and EMEA in complex and regulated environments such as financial services. We help HR and compliance teams design pre-employment screening programmes that match checks to the risk of each role, backed by ISO 27001-certified technology, a dedicated account manager and specialists in UK and international screening. Read more about the Accurate UK difference.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it illegal to lie on a CV in the UK?
It can be. Dishonestly making a false representation to gain a job can amount to fraud by false representation under the Fraud Act 2006, which carries a maximum sentence of 10 years in prison. Most cases are dealt with by withdrawing the offer or through a disciplinary process, but CV fraud can be prosecuted.
Can we withdraw a job offer if a background check is unsatisfactory?
Usually, if the offer was made conditional on satisfactory checks and the candidate knew this. Withdrawing an unconditional offer can be a breach of contract, and any decision must not be discriminatory. It is sensible to take legal advice on individual cases.
Can we dismiss an employee who lied on their CV?
Dishonesty about qualifications or experience can be a fair reason for dismissal, but the process still matters. From 1 January 2027, employees with six months’ service can claim unfair dismissal, so investigate, let the employee respond and follow a fair procedure.
How long do background checks take in the UK
It depends on the checks and countries involved. Identity and right to work checks can often be completed quickly online, and a basic DBS check takes around three days on average. Overseas employment and education checks can take longer, so start as soon as a conditional offer is made.
Do small businesses need to carry out background checks?
Every UK business must carry out right to work checks, whatever its size. Smaller businesses often have the most to lose from a bad hire, and pay-as-you-go screening lets them run the checks they need without a long-term contract.
Is your screening programme ready for 2026 and beyond? Talk to our team about reviewing your background checks, so you can hire with confidence.
Sources
- GOV.UK, Penalties for employing illegal workers
- GOV.UK, Hundreds of rogue employers targeted in illegal working crackdown (August 2024)
- GOV.UK, Illegal working penalties: codes of practice for employers (draft code, 30 June 2026)
- GOV.UK, Employer’s guide to right to work checks (draft update, 11 September 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk, SI 2026/683
- Acas, Employment Rights Act 2025
- ICO, Pre-employment vetting of candidates
- GOV.UK, Basic DBS checks
- Home Office, Guidance on the offence of failure to prevent fraud (updated 10 October 2025)
- Crown Prosecution Service, Organisations must prepare now for new fraud prevention law
- Cifas, CV fraud research (3 February 2025)
- Cifas, Workplace Fraud Trends 2025 (October 2025)
- Cifas, Insider threat data (17 April 2024)
- CIPD, Resourcing and talent planning report 2024 (September 2024)
- legislation.gov.uk, Fraud Act 2006, section 1
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.